When Research Becomes Extraction
How Academic and Corporate Research Transforms Lived Experiences into Unpaid Labor
Research has the power to amplify voices and create positive change. However, there's a growing concern about how research practices can exploit the very communities they claim to serve, turning personal stories and lived experiences into unpaid labor that primarily benefits institutions and researchers.
⚠️ Key Problems
-
No Fair Pay: People share personal stories but don't get paid for their time and emotional work
-
Schools Block People: Universities require essay writing and formal education that excludes people with learning differences
-
Emotional Harm: Sharing trauma and difficult experiences takes emotional energy that isn't valued
-
Can't Access Results: Research papers are locked behind paywalls that communities can't afford
The Extraction Problem
Traditional research often follows an extractive model where:
- Researchers collect stories and data from communities
- Participants receive little to no compensation
- Academic careers and institutional funding benefit from this "free" labor
- Communities rarely see direct benefits from the research
The Labor Reality
When people share their experiences, they're providing:
- Emotional labor: Reliving trauma or difficult experiences
- Intellectual labor: Analyzing and articulating complex situations
- Time investment: Hours spent in interviews, surveys, and follow-ups
- Expertise: Deep knowledge about their own lived realities
Power Imbalances
Research relationships often reflect broader inequalities:
- Researchers typically have more education, resources, and institutional power
- Participants may feel pressured to share personal information
- Academic language and processes can exclude community voices
- Publication and dissemination happen in spaces communities can't access
Institutional Exclusion
The same institutions that extract labor often exclude those they study:
- Academic barriers: Requiring essay writing, formal presentations, or advanced degrees
- Communication exclusion: Not accommodating different learning styles or disabilities
- Economic gatekeeping: Unpaid internships, conference fees, publication costs
- Cultural barriers: Privileging certain forms of knowledge and expression
- Accessibility failures: Physical, cognitive, and technological barriers to participation
People with learning difficulties, neurodivergent individuals, and those without formal education are systematically excluded from research careers while their experiences fuel academic success.
Who Benefits?
The current system often prioritizes:
- Researchers: Career advancement, publications, grants
- Institutions: Funding, prestige, policy influence
- Corporations: Market insights, product development
While participants may receive minimal compensation or vague promises of "helping others."
The Hidden Cost
Every personal story shared in research represents hours of unpaid emotional and intellectual labor. When multiplied across thousands of studies, this represents millions of dollars in uncompensated work, often from already marginalized communities.
🌟 Better Ways to Do Research
- 💵 Pay people fairly for sharing their stories and time
- 🤝 Work WITH communities, not just study them
- 📚 Share ownership of research results and papers
- 📋 Clear agreements about how everyone benefits
- 🎓 Train researchers about power and fairness
- ❓ Let communities choose what research questions matter
- 📖 Make research easy to read and understand
- ♿ Include people with different communication styles and abilities
- 🏠 Bring research to communities instead of fancy conferences
Good Examples Exist
Some researchers are doing better:
- 💰 Paying people as partners, not just subjects
- ✍️ Including community members as co-authors
- 💵 Sharing research money with communities
- 📋 Making easy-to-read summaries
- 🎤 Presenting in community spaces, not just universities
Questions to Ask Researchers
Before sharing your story, ask:
- 🏠 How will this help my community?
- 💵 Will I get paid fairly for my time?
- 📖 Can I read the results?
- ✋ Do I get to say how my story is used?
- 🗂️ What happens to my information later?
- ♿ Can you work with my communication style?